The server, Rob Knelly, admitted
in an interview with NJ.com that he messed up their appetizer order, but he said McCoy was rude:
“As soon as they sat down, they were pretty rude. I asked some questions, they weren’t really responsive. They were cursing, making derogatory comments. I put their order in and forgot one of their appetizers, which I apologized for. They ordered things, and once they got it, said ‘We ain’t eating this (bleep)! We don’t want it.'”
McCoy is not apologizing. He said in his media availability on Thursday he said that he tips for service and he wouldn’t change a thing about how he tipped at PYT that afternoon. He also claimed the server was the rude one.